Estate Mediation vs Litigation: Which Path Is Right for You?
When a loved one passes away, emotions run high and tensions can rise quickly. Disputes over wills, trusts, and estate administrations are sadly common in Queensland. But the good news? Not every estate dispute has to become a courtroom battle.
For many families, estate mediation in Queensland offers a more peaceful and cost-effective alternative to traditional litigation. Understanding both options can help you make an informed decision about what’s right for your situation — especially if you're considering estate litigation Brisbane families often face.
Our experienced estate litigation lawyers are here to help you understand your options and guide you through the best path forward. Whether you prefer mediation or need legal representation in court, we’ll support you every step of the way. Call us today on (07) 3703 1888 or book a consultation to speak with our team.
What Is Mediation in Estate Law?
Mediation is a confidential, structured alternative dispute resolution process where the parties involved in an estate dispute come together to find a resolution, usually with the help of a trained mediator.
Unlike a judge, the mediator doesn’t make a decision. Instead, they guide the discussion, help clarify misunderstandings, and work towards a voluntary agreement that everyone can live with. This mediation process helps families avoid prolonged litigation and emotional strain.
In Queensland, estate mediation is commonly used in matters such as:
Disagreements between beneficiaries
Family provision applications
Disputes over the will’s validity or terms
Issues around undue influence or lack of testamentary capacity
Mediation may be arranged privately or through court-annexed mediation sessions, such as those offered by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) or the Supreme Court of Queensland.
Learn more about what triggers these disputes: Why Are Wills Contested in Queensland?
When Is Estate Mediation Appropriate?
Mediation can be appropriate in most estates litigation matters, particularly when:
All parties are open to discussion
Emotions are running high, but relationships haven’t fully broken down
The dispute involves family members who want to preserve relationships
There’s a desire to resolve matters privately, without publicity
Estate mediation works well when there are multiple interpretations of the will, or when someone believes they’ve been unfairly left out. It's especially helpful in family provision applications and cases involving informal caregiving or blended families.
That said, there are times when mediation isn’t suitable:
One party refuses to participate in good faith
There's a significant power imbalance
The dispute involves fraud or criminal activity
In these cases, moving forward with estate litigation lawyers in Brisbane or elsewhere in Queensland may be necessary to protect your rights.
For examples of how disputes unfold, read:What Happens When You Contest a Will in Queensland?
Mediation vs Court: Key Differences
| Factor | Mediation | Litigation |
| Timeframe | Weeks to months | Often over a year |
| Cost | Usually lower | Higher legal fees |
| Privacy | Confidential | Public record |
| Control | Parties decide | Judge decides |
| Emotional impact | Less adversarial | Often more stressful |
Mediation gives parties more control and can help preserve relationships. It also tends to be quicker, less expensive, and more flexible. Court, while sometimes unavoidable, can increase tensions and delay closure.
However, court proceedings may be necessary if no agreement is possible, or if mediation fails to address key legal issues.
For insight into when a lawyer becomes crucial, visit: How an Estate Litigation Lawyer Can Help Resolve Disputes
Emotional and Financial Pros and Cons
Estate disputes aren’t just about money. They’re about grief, fairness, and sometimes decades of unresolved family issues. How you choose to resolve them can deeply impact your wellbeing.
Emotional Pros of Mediation:
Opportunity for open communication
Less blame-focused
Space to address personal feelings respectfully
Emotional Cons of Litigation:
Increases stress and conflict
May cause lasting rifts in families
Process can feel impersonal and rigid
Financial Pros of Mediation:
More affordable legal representation
Avoids extensive court costs
Faster resolution saves time and money
Financial Cons of Litigation:
Legal costs can escalate quickly
Uncertainty about who pays costs
Delays can reduce estate value over time
The Queensland Government and Legal Aid QLD both support the use of dispute resolution pathways like mediation to reduce court backlogs and minimise family harm.
Choosing a Lawyer Who Offers Both Paths
Not all lawyers take the same approach. Some focus solely on court proceedings, while others support their clients through both mediation and estate litigation—depending on what’s most appropriate for the situation.
At Direct Lawyers, our team—including Principal Lawyer Dion McCurdy and Estate Litigation Lawyer Liam Ellery — has extensive experience in resolving estate disputes both in and outside of court.
We are experienced lawyers in Brisbane and trusted dispute lawyers who have successfully represented clients across a wide range of estates matters.
Whether you’re navigating a difficult inheritance or trying to preserve family unity, we’ll help you resolve the dispute with confidence.
We offer mobile appointments across Brisbane, the Gold Coast, and South East Queensland. Whether you’re seeking a quiet discussion over coffee or strategic guidance in court, we’re here to help
External resource:
